Skip to content
Sign in
IMDb 6.2 HD

She's Making a List

2025 1 h 24 min Melodrama · Comedy

A holiday inspector’s professional objectivity unravels when her latest case involves a charming widower and his daughter, forcing a choice between duty and desire.

Add to favourites

Where to watch online

Official services. The link goes straight to this film.

United States 10 services With a subscription 5 services Purchase from $7.99
fuboTV With a subscription HD —
Amazon Video — $7.99 SD
Philo With a subscription HD —
Hallmark+ Amazon Channel With a subscription HD —
Hallmark+ Apple TV channel With a subscription HD —
Hallmark TV Amazon Channel With a subscription HD —
Apple TV Store — $7.99 SD
Fandango At Home — $7.99 SD
Google Play Movies — Purchase
YouTube — Purchase

Availability data by JustWatch

About the film

What it’s about

Isabel Haynes works as a Naughty or Nice inspector, evaluating children’s behavior against a strict holiday algorithm. Her latest assignment is 11-year-old Charlie Duncan, whose file seems routine. But as Isabel observes Charlie, she meets the girl’s widowed father, Jason, and finds herself drawn to him. The growing connection makes her question the rigid rules that govern her work.

What hooks you

Lacey Chabert stars as Isabel, with Andrew W. Walker as Jason. The film is directed by Stacey N. Harding. It is a holiday-themed melodrama with comedic elements, set around Christmas.

Who it’s for

It is worth a look for anyone who enjoys lighthearted seasonal romances with a touch of family warmth, or who likes stories about following one’s heart over strict rules.

In collections
Christmas
Technical details
Country
United States
Year
2025
Genres
Melodrama, Comedy
Running time
1h 24min
World premiere
Jan 1, 1970

Ratings

MOVIE․ONE · 120 votes
6.2 /10
IMDb
6.21,379
Your rating —
— /10
1 · Didn't land 10 · Masterpiece

Creative team

All 12
Director Stacey N. Harding
Starring
  1. 01 Lacey Chabert Isabel
  2. 02 Andrew W. Walker Jason (credited as: Andrew Walker) · Jason Duncan
  3. 03 Cadence Compton Charlie
  4. 04 Steve Bacic Rudolph
  5. 05 BJ Harrison Wanda
  6. 06 Louriza Tronco Heidi
  7. 07 Alessandro Miro Giuseppe
  8. 08 Georgia Blake Taylor Brooks
  9. 09 Dax Belanger Santa
  10. 10 Felix Burke Actor
  11. 11 Taylor Blake Alyssa Brooks

Reviews

0
No reviews yet Be the first to leave a review.

Similar

  1. Similar to «She's Making a List»: 'Twas the Text Before Christmas 6.5 'Twas the Text Before Christmas 2023 · Film
  2. Similar to «She's Making a List»: Christmas on Windmill Way 5.9 Christmas on Windmill Way 2023 · Film
  3. Similar to «She's Making a List»: Never Kiss a Man in a Christmas Sweater 6.5 Never Kiss a Man in a Christmas Sweater 2020 · Film
  4. Similar to «She's Making a List»: Merry Christmas, Drake & Josh 7.3 Merry Christmas, Drake & Josh 2008 · Film
  5. Similar to «She's Making a List»: Your Christmas or Mine? 6.4 Your Christmas or Mine? 2022 · Film
  6. Similar to «She's Making a List»: Holiday in Handcuffs 6.3 Holiday in Handcuffs 2007 · Film
  7. Similar to «She's Making a List»: A Cookie Cutter Christmas 6.1 A Cookie Cutter Christmas 2014 · Film
  8. Similar to «She's Making a List»: A Little Christmas Charm 6.9 A Little Christmas Charm 2020 · Film
  9. Similar to «She's Making a List»: Twinkle All the Way 6.3 Twinkle All the Way 2019 · Film
  10. Similar to «She's Making a List»: A Christmas Miracle for Daisy 5.9 A Christmas Miracle for Daisy 2021 · Film
Community

No one has written about this yet

The first piece about “She's Making a List” takes this spot. An analysis, an essay, a personal story — whatever suits you.

  1. 01It appears right here, on the page everyone looking for this title opens.
  2. 02Your name and a link to your profile go with it.
  3. 03The editor already knows which title it is about — just start with the first line.
  4. 04Your first article earns the “First article” badge on your profile.
Sign in and write