Skip to content
Sign in
IMDb 6.5 18+ HD

Should I Marry a Murderer?

2026 1 season Documentary

A pathologist's fiancé confesses to a fatal hit-and-run and burial, forcing her to choose between love and justice.

Add to favourites

Where to watch online

Official services. The link goes straight to this film.

United States 2 services With a subscription 2 services
Netflix With a subscription
Netflix Standard with Ads With a subscription

Availability data by JustWatch

About the series

What it’s about

In 2020, Glasgow pathologist Caroline Muirhead learns that her fiancé, Sandy McKellar, has confessed to killing cyclist Tony Parsons in a 2017 hit-and-run and burying the body on the Auch Estate. She must decide whether to report him to the police.

What hooks you

The series draws on Caroline Muirhead's own account and includes testimony from those involved. Josh Allott directs, with cinematography by Stefano Ferrari and music by Joel Cadbury.

Who it’s for

It suits viewers who appreciate true crime documentaries that focus on moral dilemmas and the personal cost of doing the right thing, and those interested in Scottish settings and real-life investigations.

Technical details
Country
United States
Year
2026
Genre
Documentary
Age rating
18+
MPAA
TV-MA
Status
Off air
World premiere
Apr 29, 2026

Ratings

MOVIE․ONE · 359 votes
7.0 /10
IMDb
6.52,016
Kinopoisk
6.9199
Your rating —
— /10
1 · Didn't land 10 · Masterpiece

Creative team

All 10
Director Josh Allott

Reviews

0
No reviews yet Be the first to leave a review.

Similar

  1. Similar to «Should I Marry a Murderer?»: Trust Me: The False Prophet 7.9 Trust Me: The False Prophet 2026 · Series
  2. Similar to «Should I Marry a Murderer?»: Conversations with a Killer: The Jeffrey Dahmer Tapes 7.3 Conversations with a Killer: The Jeffrey Dahmer Tapes 2022 · Series
  3. Similar to «Should I Marry a Murderer?»: The Idaho Murders: College Nightmare 6.8 The Idaho Murders: College Nightmare 2026 · Series
  4. Similar to «Should I Marry a Murderer?»: Death of the Pastor's Wife 7.3 Death of the Pastor's Wife 2026 · Series
  5. Similar to «Should I Marry a Murderer?»: The Yogurt Shop Murders 6.8 The Yogurt Shop Murders 2025 · Series
  6. Similar to «Should I Marry a Murderer?»: Crime Scene: The Texas Killing Fields 6.5 Crime Scene: The Texas Killing Fields 2022 · Series
  7. Similar to «Should I Marry a Murderer?»: Killer Sally 6.7 Killer Sally 2022 · Series
  8. Similar to «Should I Marry a Murderer?»: Homicide Hunter: Lt Joe Kenda 8.9 Homicide Hunter: Lt Joe Kenda 2011 · Series
  9. Similar to «Should I Marry a Murderer?»: Dateline 6.6 Dateline 1992 · Series
  10. Similar to «Should I Marry a Murderer?»: I AM A KILLER 6.9 I AM A KILLER 2018 · Series
Community

No one has written about this yet

The first piece about “Should I Marry a Murderer?” takes this spot. An analysis, an essay, a personal story — whatever suits you.

  1. 01It appears right here, on the page everyone looking for this title opens.
  2. 02Your name and a link to your profile go with it.
  3. 03The editor already knows which title it is about — just start with the first line.
  4. 04Your first article earns the “First article” badge on your profile.