Should I Marry a Murderer?
A pathologist's fiancé confesses to a fatal hit-and-run and burial, forcing her to choose between love and justice.
Where to watch online
Official services. The link goes straight to this film.
Availability data by JustWatch
About the series
What it’s about
In 2020, Glasgow pathologist Caroline Muirhead learns that her fiancé, Sandy McKellar, has confessed to killing cyclist Tony Parsons in a 2017 hit-and-run and burying the body on the Auch Estate. She must decide whether to report him to the police.
What hooks you
The series draws on Caroline Muirhead's own account and includes testimony from those involved. Josh Allott directs, with cinematography by Stefano Ferrari and music by Joel Cadbury.
Who it’s for
It suits viewers who appreciate true crime documentaries that focus on moral dilemmas and the personal cost of doing the right thing, and those interested in Scottish settings and real-life investigations.
- Country
- United States
- Year
- 2026
- Genre
- Documentary
- Age rating
- 18+
- MPAA
- TV-MA
- Status
- Off air
- World premiere
- Apr 29, 2026
Ratings
MOVIE․ONE · 359 votesCreative team
All 10-
01
Caroline Muirhead
plays himself
-
02
Sandy McKellar
plays himself, archive footage
-
03
James O'Kelly
Caroline's Friend, plays himself (credited as: James)
-
04
Margaret Muirhead
Caroline's Mother, plays herself (credited as: Margaret)
-
05
Stephen Muirhead
Caroline's Father, plays himself (credited as: Stephen)
-
06
Tony Parsons
Murder Victim, plays himself, archive footage
- 07 James Crouch Sandy McKellar
-
08
Robert McKellar
Sandy's Twin Brother, plays himself, archive footage
-
09
Ninon Noiret
Caroline Muirhead
Reviews
0Similar
-
7.9
Trust Me: The False Prophet
-
7.3
Conversations with a Killer: The Jeffrey Dahmer Tapes
-
6.8
The Idaho Murders: College Nightmare
-
7.3
Death of the Pastor's Wife
-
6.8
The Yogurt Shop Murders
-
6.5
Crime Scene: The Texas Killing Fields
-
6.7
Killer Sally
-
8.9
Homicide Hunter: Lt Joe Kenda
-
6.6
Dateline
-
6.9
I AM A KILLER
No one has written about this yet
The first piece about “Should I Marry a Murderer?” takes this spot. An analysis, an essay, a personal story — whatever suits you.
- 01It appears right here, on the page everyone looking for this title opens.
- 02Your name and a link to your profile go with it.
- 03The editor already knows which title it is about — just start with the first line.
- 04Your first article earns the “First article” badge on your profile.
Share
Should I Marry a Murderer? (2026)